Four Reasons Why New Leaders Fail to Influence Others

“People who are persuasive understand they aren’t selling an idea or demanding results or pleading to be heard.  They know they’re building relationships founded on an emotional connection.”  - Arlene Dickinson

If you are a new leader or responsible for developing new leaders, here are four reasons why leaders fail to influence.  These four reasons were shared at a seminar I attended with leadership expert John C. Maxwell and I have expanded on them here.

Review these four reasons and select specific actions to help a new leader expand their leadership influence.

  1. They are not effective communicators.

James Humes quoted “The art of communication is the language of leadership.”  It is a fundamental tool for a leader to possess.  However, a study discovered that 80% of leaders think they are better communicators than they really are.  Further studies place communication problems at the top of employee workplace frustrations.

Helping new leaders become aware of the importance of communication as a leadership skill, as well as their strengths and gaps in this area, is imperative.  This will require you to create an action plan to continually improve their communication skills.  One way to do this is to complete a personality assessment such as Everything DiSC®.  New leaders will learn how they prefer to communicate and how it may be perceived positively or negatively by other personality styles.  They will also learn new ways to adapt their styles to communicate more effectively with others.

  1. They do not have an attitude or spirit to help others.

We have limited control over what we experience, but we have complete control over our attitudes around it.  Anthony Robbins quoted in his book, Unlimited Power, “Nothing has any meaning except the meaning you give it.”  If new leaders view employees as a tool to be used versus a resource they need to nurture, morale will suffer and you will get minimum effort from people.  However, if a new leader believes their role is to support team members to perform their best work, they will seek out ways to add value to them.

Coach new leaders to choose a positive attitude and recognize that their role is not to avoid problems, but rather help people solve problems.  They do not have the luxury to complain about them.  “Having a bad day” is not an option for a leader.  Nor is ignoring the needs of the people they lead.

  1. They have not had an influence connector.

When a person is new to leadership they may encounter situations where they need to borrow influence and credibility from someone else.  Early in my career, I was given a development opportunity to lead a multi-national team who were tasked with creating a leadership training program.  Many of these team members had more experience and tenure than I did.  When I experienced challenges with the team making this initiative a top priority among their other work responsibilities, I had to borrow influence from my leader.

To help new leaders get a head start on building their influence, identify potential influence gaps and seek ways to connect the new leader to influence connectors - people in the organization who are valued and trusted influencers.  When it is perceived that these people value the new leader, it will increase the pace at which the new leader can build their own credibility and grow their influence.

  1. They have not been taught how influence works.

Influence is at its lowest level when the new leader receives their title.  If a leader relies solely on positional influence, they tend to control others through company policies, procedures, rules and regulations.  Force, intimidation, manipulation, and because “I am the boss” methods of influence are the lowest and most negative forms of influence.

Influence grows in stages as new leaders develop relationships with others. Help new leaders identify ways they can intentionally add value to others.   In fact, John Maxwell stated that “if you want to incredibly increase your influence, do one thing everyday to add value to others”.  Help new leaders add value to others and people won’t be asking them the question “What have you done for me lately?”

What is one action you can take today to support a new leader or one you want to groom for a future leadership role?

Read more articles on leading with influence: 

7 Questions New Leaders Want Answered

10 Ways to Increase Your Influence

Believing in People Brings Out the Best in People

Three Easy Steps to Positively Influence Others

Lisa Holden Rovers, MSc, CPHR, PCC, is the Founder of Workplace Matters. Since 2005, she has been coaching small and mid-sized business leaders to grow their influence and inspire their teams to thrive. With her data-driven coaching and training approach, Lisa helps clients improve collaboration, productivity, and well-being. As a certified leadership and team coach, Lisa utilizes solutions like Everything DiSC® and The Five Behaviors® to help clients leverage their strengths and build high-performing teams.

let's connect!

Grow as a Leader and Thrive as a Team!

Stay connected to receive future lessons straight to your inbox. 

We respect your privacy.